How renting and buying are compared
Buyer net worth = home value × (1 − selling cost share) − mortgage balance + buyer investments. Renter net worth = renter investments. Each month, investments grow by annual return ÷ 12, then the cheaper option invests the cost difference.
- Start renter investments with the deposit plus buying costs.
- Calculate the mortgage and costs on the start-of-month home value.
- Grow both portfolios, then invest savings on the cheaper side.
- Update the mortgage and home value; increase rent each year.
- Compare wealth after selling costs at each year end.
Worked example: For a 500,000 home, 100,000 deposit and 20,000 buying costs, a 6% mortgage over 30 years costs 2,398.20 a month. With the default growth and cost assumptions, buying is ahead by 4,551.75 after 10 years.
Rent versus buy examples
| Years | Home growth (%) | Renting is ahead by | Buyer net worth | Renter net worth |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5 | 3% | 16,888.66 | 195,826.87 | 212,715.53 |
| 10 | 3% | 4,551.75 | 323,776.13 | 319,224.38 |
| 10 | 0% | 154,058.59 | 155,257.10 | 309,315.69 |
| 20 | 3% | 87,752.11 | 683,112.62 | 595,360.51 |
Swipe the table sideways to see the rest.
Other inputs use the defaults. These are illustrations, not forecasts.
The assumptions that swing the answer
Property growth, rent growth, the return on the deposit if invested, the years you stay, and buying and selling costs all move the result.
At the page defaults ($500,000 home, $100,000 deposit, 6% mortgage, $2,000 rent, 3% growth, 10 years), buying is ahead by $4,551.75. With property growth 2 points lower (1%), renting is ahead by $105,923.10.
Not just money
Renting gives flexibility to move. Owning gives security of tenure, but you pay for maintenance and repairs yourself.
Things to consider
- Test several growth and return assumptions.
- Include all upfront buying costs.
- Ownership costs rise with home value.
- Mortgage payments stop when the loan is repaid.
- Positive differences favour buying.
- A crossover need not stay positive later.
Frequently asked questions
What matters most in rent vs buy?
The growth, rent and return assumptions. At the defaults, buying is ahead by $4,551.75 after 10 years; with 1% growth instead of 3%, renting is ahead by $105,923.10.
Is it better to rent or buy?
It depends on costs, how long you stay, property growth and investment returns. This calculator compares net worth using your assumptions. It does not measure flexibility, security or personal preferences.
What does the break-even point mean?
It is the first whole year, up to year 40, when buyer net worth is at least renter net worth after selling costs. The same monthly model is used at every year end. Buying can fall behind again if assumptions favour renting later.
Which costs do owners pay that renters do not?
Owners may pay buying fees, rates, insurance, maintenance and selling fees. Enter upfront costs separately and ongoing costs as an annual share of home value. The Mortgage Calculator helps check loan repayments.
Why does the investment return matter?
Money used for a deposit and buying costs cannot also be invested. The renter invests that starting amount, and either side invests monthly cost savings. This opportunity cost can change the comparison. The Compound Interest Calculator explores investment growth separately.
What are the limits of this model?
Tax treatment varies and no tax rules are included. Mortgage rates and growth assumptions stay constant. Investment returns use the annual rate divided by 12; home growth uses an effective annual rate. Rent rises yearly. Moving costs, investment fees, inflation and lifestyle factors are not modelled. Use the Rental Yield Calculator for a rental property income estimate.